Please be sure to read the previous articles in this series.
Moving onward to the penultimate page from TMNT #1 with provenance proof, Page 38 is ready to attest with a wealth of information. Not only does Page 38 contribute evidence that strengthens the case for The TMNT #1 Production Negatives, it also provides an unexpected “little hint” of data; an additional clue that provides insight into a widely-believed theory about The TMNT #1 Production Negatives while, in the process, could prove something significant about an obscure TMNT comic book.
The evidence Page 38 has to reveal begins at the top of the page – the box with Donatello shouting, “NO!” and throwing his bo staff. The negative and the 1st & 2nd printing all have unique background shading in that box, consistently rendered throughout. However, the 3rd printing has no shading at all in that box – a completely white background. An obvious piece of evidence that ties The TMNT #1 Production Negatives to the 1st & 2nd printings.
While the aforementioned clue at the top of Page 38 is justifiably significant, what’s found at the bottom might just prove to be the most valuable in the long run. Just below the bottom two panels on Page 38 are two unique streaks or lines, very similar to the kinds of marks found on Pages 33 & 35. Just as with the marks on those pages, the marks on this page can be traced to an anomaly on the negative. However, unlike Pages 33 & 35, these small lines appear ONLY on the negative and the 2nd printing but are completely missing from both the 1st and 3rd printings. The absence of these marks from the 3rd printing could be anticipated but their omission from the 1st printing is surprising; a completely unexpected and inconsistent finding. Might this actually be the first piece of evidence from the pages of TMNT #1 that disproves the theory about The TMNT #1 Production Negatives? Thankfully, quite the opposite.
The discovery of this anomaly does initially present more questions than answers. It doesn’t make sense in light of all the other evidence (including that found at the top of Page 38); evidence that clearly indicates both the 1st & 2nd printings came from The TMNT #1 Production Negatives. However, upon closer inspection of the 1st printing (Page 38), a completely different anomaly can be seen – the bottom line of the left-most panel is broken and warped and looks nothing like that same line in the 2nd and 3rd printings. This is a peculiar abnormality that exists ONLY in the 1st printing and is in the same area where the streaks should have been. It’s essentially a printing error that’s found only in the 1st printing; even the negative doesn’t depict this strange deviation. Seemingly, it’s an indication that something peculiar happened only to the 1st printing (Page 38) during the production process. But what? And how?
Further investigation of this unique error presents a couple possibilities that help explain why this deviation was found only in the 1st printing. Previous articles in this series have documented the very involved and intricate steps of the offset printing process; numerous parts that are prone to some error introduction and aren’t always an exact science. Since the negative clearly doesn’t have this error, it had to be introduced by something “post-negative” in the production process for the 1st printing – basically any step performed AFTER the negative was created. However, given the appearance of the error, it was almost certainly caused by one of two things: the printing plate or the press blanket. And there’s only one way to know for sure – to look at Page 38 from all 3,275 copies of TMNT #1 1st printing! Of course, since that’s not really possible, all that can actually be done to try and discern the origin is to look at Page 38 from as many TMNT #1 1st printing copies as possible. Here’s why.
If the error in the 1st printing at the bottom of Page 38 is found in every copy (or as many as can be seen) of TMNT #1 1st printing AND that error is consistent (looks the same – rendered identically) among all copies, then the printing plate is the likely cause of this anomaly. The printing plate is a lot like the negative in that, once it’s made, it’s unchanging – fixed and permanent. With that said, printing plates do wear out – only good for a fixed amount of use – and when they wear out, new printing plates are again made from the same negatives. However, only one set of printing plates would have been required for the very small press run of TMNT #1 1st printing (3,275 copies). Any printing error present on the printing plate used for Page 38 of the 1st printing would persist throughout all 3,275 copies of TMNT #1 1st printing.
However, if the error in the 1st printing at the bottom of Page 38 is NOT found in every copy of TMNT #1 1st printing OR that error is inconsistent (looks different – dissimilar) between multiple copies, then the press blanket was the likely cause of this anomaly. The press blanket is used to get the printing plate image transferred to the printed paper. Because the press blanket handles ink coverage / saturation, it is the one part of the process that could produce printed variations on the same page within the same print run. Page 38 printed at the beginning of the press run might have this error while Page 38 printed at the end of the press run might not (or vice versa). If, at some point during the press run of Page 38 from the 1st printing, the ink coverage on the printing plate or the press blanket was inconsistent, then this error could manifest itself. With that in mind, consider this. The possible variability described above could also mean one further crazy scenario with Page 38 of the 1st printing. If the press blanket‘s ink coverage somehow obscured (or warped) that bottom line on only some Page 38‘s (eliminating the small streaks below the line), then some Page 38’s of the 1st printing could actually depict those two small streaks at the bottom, just like the streaks that the negative and the 2nd printing have. How bizarre would that be?
Ultimately, this all just boils down to one of two possibilities. Either ALL copies of TMNT #1 1st printing have this error at the bottom of Page 38 or only SOME copies have it. I’m personally partial to the cause being the printing plate and that all TMNT #1 1st printing copies have this error on Page 38. Only one way to find out though, right? 😉 If you own (or have access to) a raw copy of TMNT #1 1st printing, open it up to Page 38 and find out. And then, make sure to take a picture and send it to me. I’d like to someday find out and be sure (or, more sure).
It is this unique little error at the bottom of Page 38 in the 1st printing that is the aforementioned “little hint” of information (from the first paragraph if you recall). While it can’t testify to the authenticity of The TMNT #1 Production Negatives like the other clues do, it absolutely could do something very important and unexpected. However, before that can be discussed, there’s a second piece of evidence that hasn’t yet been revealed; something that goes hand-in-hand with the error on Page 38. Because that piece of evidence is critical and it exists on the ninth and final page of evidence from TMNT #1, elaboration must wait until Part 20; after one final piece in the “page-puzzle” has been revealed.
And with that, only that one final page from TMNT #1 remains; a page with secrets and evidence so powerful that it removes any doubt. This last page unearths the ultimate of clues, so perfectly authenticating The TMNT #1 Production Negatives that it might just be the only proof needed to verify that the 1st & 2nd printings came from The TMNT #1 Production Negatives.
-
TMNT #1 1st printing - Page 38 -
TMNT #1 2nd printing - Page 38 -
TMNT #1 3rd printing - Page 38 -
The TMNT #1 Production Negatives - Page 38 -
TMNT #1 1st printing - Page 38 (bottom) -
TMNT #1 Page 38 (top) - Negative to Printing Comparison -
TMNT #1 Page 38 (bottom) - Negative to Printing Comparison -
The TMNT #1 Production Negatives: Part 18 -
The TMNT #1 Production Negatives: Parts 12-19
Sources: - The Collection of Mat Allen - TMNT #1 1st printing page images (used with permission) - PrintWiki - The Free Encyclopedia of Print





Comments are closed.