The TMNT #1 Production Negatives: Part 19 – Evidence From Page 29 (a.k.a., “The Smoking Gun!”)



Please be sure to read the previous articles in this series.


TMNT #1 1st printing – Page 29

It’s time for the final page of TMNT #1 to unleash all it has to say about the relationship between The TMNT #1 Production Negatives and the 1st & 2nd printings of TMNT #1 – Page 29.  Although the evidence that exists throughout TMNT #1 can hardly be called insignificant, what’s found on Page 29 is literally “The Smoking Gun” of it all.  While the previous eight pages were revealed in sequential page order, Page 29 was purposely saved for last because…the best should ALWAYS be saved for last.

As was the case with Page 38, Page 29 also contains two major pieces of evidence.  One undoubtedly & undeniably solidifies the authenticity of The TMNT #1 Production Negatives.  The other partners with the error on Page 38 to reveal very important and unexpected possibilities about The TMNT #1 Production Negatives and a significant (lesser-known) piece of TMNT comic book history.

TMNT #1 Page 29 (side) – Negative to Printing Comparison

It’s been said time and time again that “a picture is worth a thousand words.”  This is no less true of the evidence that exists in the bottom right corner of TMNT #1, Page 29; the most telling piece of proof in existence for the legitimacy of The TMNT #1 Production Negatives.  In that bottom right corner of Page 29 in the 1st & 2nd printings, the line on the right near the page number appears to be “broken” or missing.  However, that same place in the 3rd printing shows a whole line; “unbroken” and complete while also connecting to the adjacent line above.  Nothing really too surprising.  It’s a familiar scenario that plays out many times in TMNT #1; one printing has something that the other two don’t (or vice versa).  But one look at the negative and this routine evidence becomes “The Smoking Gun.”

The TMNT #1 Production Negatives – Page 29

In the lower right corner of the negative for Page 29, the line predicted to be missing is actually there!  That line is fully rendered on the negative – correct, complete, and unbroken – just as it appears on the 3rd printing.  Closer inspection reveals the presence of red tape on the negative that appears to obscure that line – in the exact place where that line is missing from the 1st & 2nd printings.  Not only is that red tape positioned identically, the unique shape at the bottom of tape (where it was torn) can also be seen on the 1st & 2nd printings.  The red tape exists on the negative at the precise place where that line is missing from the 1st & 2nd printings AND with the exact shape of the tape tear precisely duplicated.  Where that line breaks on Page 29 of the 1st & 2nd printings is exactly where the red tape exists on the negative.  The unique shape at the bottom of that red tape is a completely random occurrence – an impossibility to duplicate in multiple printings of TMNT #1 without the exact same source having been used for both.  The TMNT #1 Production Negatives!

So, what exactly is that red tape and what is it used for?  It’s a piece of opaque red lithographers tape that is widely used in the printing industry to hide or mask portions of the negative (opaquing); to prevent those areas of the negative from transferring to the printing plate and subsequently, the printed pages.  For some unknown reason, lithographers tape was adhered to the Page 29 negative right over that line – a line that is part of the page image and shouldn’t have been opaqued.  Had tape like this been used to mask the imperfections on the negatives for Pages 33, 35, & 38, those anomalies would have never made it to the printed pages.  But why WASN’T this tape used on Pages 33, 35, & 38 to mask what should have been hidden but WAS used on Page 29 to mask what shouldn’t have been hidden?  That’s a question that is likely to forever remain unanswered.  Although the red tape on the Page 29 negative is an enigma, it’s also THE defining piece of evidence that links The TMNT #1 Production Negatives to the 1st & 2nd printings of TMNT #1.  There can be no doubt.

TMNT #1 Page 29 (bottom) – Negative to Printing Comparison

While the negative for Page 29 clearly provides the “The Smoking Gun” of evidence that authenticates The TMNT #1 Production Negatives, it also provides something more – that aforementioned unexpected “little hint” of information.  And it comes in the form of yet another printing mistake.

As was revealed in Part 18, two pages from TMNT #1 contain unique printing errors that, together, provide very important and unexpected possibilities.  It turns out that Page 38 is not the only page in TMNT #1 with a crazy error that’s found in only one of the first three printings and isn’t present on the negative.  Page 29 also contains an interesting little error that’s not found on the negative – but this one is present ONLY in the 2nd printing.  At the bottom of Page 29 in the 2nd printing, imperfections can be seen in the middle of the Foot Soldier’s back.  These blemishes cause breaks in the bottom bounding box line and leave a significant void in what was intended to be a fully black area.  Since the 1st & 3rd printings don’t have these flaws (nor does the negative), the situation with Page 29 is nearly identical to that seen on Page 38 – a printing error caused by either the printing plate or the press blanket.  Pretty much everything documented in Part 18 for the error on Page 38 holds true for Page 29.  Either ALL copies of TMNT #1 2nd printing have this error at the bottom of Page 29 or only SOME copies have it; as of writing this article, every copy I’ve seen of the 2nd printing contains this error. If you have a 2nd printing copy without this error on Page 29, please contact me.

With Page 29‘s secrets out in the open, there’s now just one thing left to do – find out what the errors on Pages 29 & 38 have to do with each other.

Sources: 
- The Collection of Mat Allen - TMNT #1 1st printing page images (used with permission)
- PrintWiki - The Free Encyclopedia of Print
×

Comments are closed.

Latest Post

TMNT Vol. I #1 (Mirage) 1st Printing Authentication

“How can I verify that a copy of TMNT #1 is a 1st Printing?” That’s the question I hear most often from collectors – and, of course, it’s a very important question to ask, especially if you’re seeking to buy such a sought-after and valuable collectible. It’s critical for collectors to find an accurate and […]

Labeling the Different Volumes of “Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles” Comics

IDW Publishing recently announced a relaunch of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles title that will be written by Eisner-award-winning writer Jason Aaron. This new series will officially become the seventh volume of comics to be published with the title Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. However, it will become known as “Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Vol. VI.”  […]

Bring The TMNT #1 Production Negatives Exhibit To Your Local Convention / Event !

It’s time for your convention / event to receive an upgrade !!! Are you a convention or event organizer looking to feature something unique while also enhancing the overall experience for your attendees? Maybe you’re a pop-culture fan with a favorite local show where you’d love to see something different and extraordinary. When it comes […]